That supper had a backstory.
In the spring of 1965 the Cleveland Orchestra under George Szell toured the Soviet Union. In Moscow, U.S. Ambassador Foy D. Kohler gave a reception in the orchestra's honor. Among the Soviet guests were Rostropovich and Kondrashin; Vishnevskaya was not there.
Nor were the Hickses themselves — devoted followers of the Cleveland Orchestra. They heard about the Moscow evening through friends in Maine whose daughter was the ambassador's personal secretary. And now, in the autumn, the supper in Shaker Heights became a kind of thank-you: the American friends were hosting the guests from Moscow.
Behind the official concert posters a world of personal acquaintance and friendship opens up — a world in which musicians found a common language far more easily than politicians.
How Sol Hurok Lost Two Great Musicians
Now let us go back a month, to New York.
On October 14, 1965, the famous American impresario Sol Hurok invited his Soviet guests to lunch at Le Pavillon, an elegant French restaurant on East 57th Street.
An extraordinary company gathered at the table: David Oistrakh and his wife, Mstislav Rostropovich and Galina Vishnevskaya, and the conductor Kirill Kondrashin.
The next day the Moscow Philharmonic was to open a six-week American tour at Carnegie Hall.
After lunch Hurok put the ladies in his limousine and headed for his office on Fifth Avenue. He was sure Kondrashin and an agency staffer would walk Oistrakh and Rostropovich over.
Kondrashin, for his part, assumed both musicians had left with Hurok.
Oistrakh and Rostropovich, meanwhile, finding themselves unescorted, went off to look at New York's shop windows.
Forty minutes later everyone was finally reunited at the impresario's office.
The next day The New York Times reported the incident under the headline "Hurok Misplaces 2 Stars Briefly."
Fortunately, the tour was never in danger.
What is more, all eleven Carnegie Hall concerts were already sold out, and Hurok announced an additional performance at Madison Square Garden on November 8.
The same article preserved the lunch-table conversation.
Kondrashin spoke of the remarkable growth of musical life in the Soviet Union — new concert halls, conservatories and symphony orchestras, including in Siberia.
And Vishnevskaya remarked that opera at home was in such enormous demand that singers sometimes found it hard to expand their repertoire: audiences wanted above all to hear their beloved Russian and Italian works.
This small detail says a great deal about her. Even at a festive lunch in New York, she was still thinking about the theatre, the repertoire and her audience.
Seventeen Floors Without an Elevator
The 1965 American tour was full of adventures.
On November 9, New York was plunged into darkness by the famous Northeast blackout.
Rostropovich and Vishnevskaya were on the seventeenth floor of the Warwick Hotel.
The elevators stopped. The musicians had to walk down the stairs, carrying their luggage — and the cello.
Later, with his characteristic humor, Rostropovich told Dr. Gross about it over the phone, in Russian: "It was so dark I couldn't even see my wife."
Two days later Vishnevskaya was singing at Severance Hall.
And it is hard to imagine that anyone in the hall, listening to her Tchaikovsky, suspected what the singer and her husband had just been through.
Another Russian Concert in Cleveland
On Sunday, November 14, 1965, Cleveland witnessed another major musical event.
At Music Hall, part of the Cleveland Public Auditorium complex, the Moscow Philharmonic performed under Kirill Kondrashin.
The soloist was Igor Oistrakh — son of David Oistrakh, whom Hurok had briefly lost in New York a month earlier. That weekend Igor Oistrakh and his wife Natasha also stayed with the Grosses, where Rostropovich joined them.
Father and son both took part in the American tour, appearing in different cities and programs.
Cleveland heard the Brahms Violin Concerto, Olivier Messiaen's Les Offrandes oubliées and Mahler's Ninth Symphony.
The next day critic Frank Hruby published his review in The Cleveland Press: "Moscow Orchestra Rates Praise Here."
He praised the Moscow ensemble's mastery and Igor Oistrakh's playing, though the Mahler Ninth drew a more reserved response.
Within a few November days, Cleveland heard Galina Vishnevskaya, Kirill Kondrashin, Igor Oistrakh and the Moscow Philharmonic.
And all this happened in the very year the Cleveland Orchestra made its historic tour of the Soviet Union.
The musical exchange went both ways — and was astonishingly rich.
An Unexpected Meeting with Isadora Duncan
But the story turned out to have one more, entirely unexpected sequel.
Who was Sol Hurok, the man who organized the Soviet musicians' American tour?
He was born in the Russian Empire as Solomon Gurkov, emigrated to the United States, and became one of the most influential impresarios of the twentieth century.
Among the artists he worked with were Anna Pavlova, Isadora Duncan and many other great performers.
And here we suddenly return to a story we recently told readers of the Russian Garden Gazette.
On December 10, 1922, Isadora Duncan performed at the Cleveland Public Auditorium.
She had come to America with her young husband, the Russian poet Sergei Yesenin.
The performance drew some nine thousand people. Among the witnesses that evening was the young American poet Hart Crane.
Duncan's American tour was managed by Sol Hurok.
The very man who, forty-three years later, invited Galina Vishnevskaya, Rostropovich, Oistrakh and Kondrashin to lunch.
This is where our two stories unexpectedly meet.
In 1922 Hurok brought to America Isadora Duncan, the artist who overturned ideas about dance.
In 1965 he presented outstanding Soviet musicians, among them Galina Vishnevskaya.
And both tours passed through Cleveland.
Music That Keeps Bringing People Together
The Cleveland connections did not end there.
In May 1969 Mstislav Rostropovich and David Oistrakh recorded the Brahms Double Concerto with the Cleveland Orchestra under George Szell.
That recording became one of the remarkable pages in the orchestra's history.
And the friendship of Rostropovich and Vishnevskaya with their American acquaintances continued beyond the concert hall.
In December 1965 they gave an unusual private recital in New Jersey to thank two dentists who had helped them. Among the guests was Cleveland's own Dr. Jerome Gross.
The New York Times reported on this intimate evening for about sixty listeners.
How many more such stories lie hidden in old newspapers, letters and family archives?
We began our research with a simple wish: to mark Galina Vishnevskaya's centenary and remember her performances in Cleveland.
Instead we discovered a whole world — a world where music connected people across oceans and borders, where great artists befriended doctors, conductors met American colleagues, and a famous impresario occasionally lost his stars in the middle of New York.
But at the heart of this story remains Galina Vishnevskaya.
A woman who survived the Siege of Leningrad, reached the summit of operatic art, shared with Rostropovich years of fame, trial and exile, and kept her dignity and her convictions.
In November 1965 her voice filled Severance Hall.
Today, sixty-one years later, we return to that evening thanks to the people who heard her, wrote about her and preserved their impressions on the pages of newspapers.
And perhaps this is the best way to mark a great singer's centenary — not simply to repeat the familiar facts of her biography, but to bring back to life one of the evenings when her art became part of our city's history.
Happy birthday, Galina Pavlovna!